American Identity

American: An Adjective Disguised as a Noun

Although I’ve been taught American history, literature, and culture since preschool, for some reason I hadn’t quite identified what defined America until I read Roderick Nash’s “Wilderness and the American Mind” in my Early American Literature class. From reading Nash’s work I realized that what characterizes America is wilderness, and that the term “wilderness” itself is a problematic word. As Nash writes in the first line of the prologue, “‘Wilderness’ has a deceptive concreteness at first glance. The difficulty is that while the word is a noun it acts like an adjective.” Interestingly, if you replace “wilderness” with “American,” his statement holds remarkably true.

Just as “wilderness” could mean either an uncivilized forest containing the absence of man, or an island visited as a hot vacation spot, the term “American” just depends. People question what constitutes American identity and often contemplate, cringe, or explain themselves when they’re called American. Merriam Webster defines “American” as “a person born, raised, or living in the U.S.” or in “North America or South America,” which appears to be an accept-all-points-of-view definition. This is so because every person in the world has a different perspective of what “American” means, which frequently results in confusion or even trouble.

forest
Wilderness? | Photo from Henderson-art
tahiti_islands2
Or Wilderness? | Photo from Blogspot

Recently I had such an encounter with a girl from Europe who told me I look and sound native American. Being born of Polish parents, I was confused because I thought she meant I looked like the Native American Indians. In the U.S., children are taught that the term Native American refers to the original peoples of America who lived in the land before the Puritans took over, and that the term Indian was incorrect and refers to citizens of India. It wasn’t until I thought about our conversation later on that I realized she meant I look and sound like I come from generations of people living in America and like I’m not the first of my family to be born in America. In most other nations, people refer to being originally from a country as being “native” of it— only in America does “native” not always have that same meaning.

As for the word “American,” and whether or not I identify as an American—it depends on the context. When the girl said I “looked” American, I didn’t take it very well, because what does an American look like? We all look different! We sound different as well, but I understand that she means I don’t sound British or Australian, or have a Polish accent. I could identify as American simply because I was born and raised in the U.S., but usually I’m quick to mention my parents are from Poland and that I speak Polish too. Therefore, although “American” is a noun as Merriam Webster states, it is actually acts like an adjective, since one could be described as appearing like a person born, raised, or living in the Americas— or really just the U.S., because South Americans and Canadians are called according to the names of their nations— but not actually be it—whatever being American means.

Indeed, the terms “American” and “wilderness” are adjectives disguised as nouns.

 

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “American: An Adjective Disguised as a Noun

  1. I love this! You pose some really provocative questions, and I’m glad you addressed them all. You especially got me with your native American/Native American piece–we are not the only place to have imposed on a group of people previously living in an area to later be colonized (take Africa for example). Your talk of “what does an American look like?” is also really thought provoking, because I, too, tried to address this (albeit less articulately) because appearance is so often not looked past when we consider what makes an “American”. Lastly, your title where you take the construct of American as an adjective and not a noun really struck me as brilliant–you hit the nail on the head in my book.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I enjoyed this post, it was a good read. I liked how you explored the relativity of the terms “wilderness” and “american” and I loved how your personal anecdote reflected this ambiguity and confusion in language and words. There is a lot of wiggle room in the word “American” and I liked how you portrayed how layered an identity, like your own, can be and still be categorized as American. You have a really interesting title that really summarizes the direction of your post and I feel your pictures helped your entire post seem professional, like one a legit journalist would post.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. I really enjoyed your blog! You have my mind racing with questions and I don’t know where to begin even explaining my thoughts. You did such a good job poking at the controversial and not so easily explained sections of what it means to be an American. Your argument that the term American is a noun that acts as an adjective is genius. You have summed up my thoughts in such a simple way. Your personal anecdote put the icing on the cake for me. It put my thoughts on what it means to be American into an image. Everyone defines this term differently and it differs based on experience, laws, etc.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s