Reflections on Hope Leslie

Catharine Sedgwick, You should have named your book “Magawisca”


        As I read Sedgwick’s “Hope Leslie”, I found that the real heroine of the story was truly Magawisca. Sedgwick’s portrayal of her main character Hope Leslie, creates the main story line for another central character named Magawisca. I believe that the title of Sedgwick’s book should have been “Magawisca”. Magawisca’s character gave a genuine and truthful portrayal of the Indian identity. According to Kate Porter in her article, Designing the Future: Hope, Magawisca & Their People’s Struggles for Dominance in Colonial America, she makes this point:

“Similarly, when describing Magawisca, the narrator offers praise for her appearance, saying, “Her form was slender, flexible, and graceful and there was a freedom and loftiness in her movement which though tempered with modesty, expressed a consciousness of high birth her face was beautiful even to a European eye” (23). The narrator continues, “this daughter of a chieftain had an air of wild and fantastic grace, that harmonized well with the noble demeanor and peculiar beauty of the savage” (23). So, while the narrator does describe her as wild and savage, as readers might expect from an Indian, Magawisca also possesses many attributes admired by the Anglo-American culture. Not only can the European eye can appreciate her beauty, but this young woman is also noble and modest, attributes we may not expect to find in an Indian girl.”

       I agree with Porter. Magawisca seems to be given a more powerful, natural, and beautiful approach. The further I read it seemed that Magawisca created a way for both the Pequot Indians and Hope Leslie’s people to understand each other. It seemed as if she were playing devil’s advocate because she tries to portray the goodness of her people, but also showing the goodness to her father when he seeks revenge in trying to kill Everell. Magawisca has created a new identity for her people in her approach. She is no longer savage, but she is now humanized with nobility, feelings, and hope for the future with the relations of her people.

Photo Credit to Pinterest

        If Magawisca had not approached Miss Hope Leslie, then none of the events of the story would have unfolded. Magawisca is the key character to the unfolding of all events. She was the one who arranged for Hope and her sister to meet. Magawisca also set her pride aside, becoming noble and compassionate. We can see this when she changes her pride to try to comfort Hope as she cries for her sister. “There was a cord in Magawisca’s heart that needed but the touch of tenderness to respond in harmony; her pride vanished, and her indignation gave place to sympathy.” She was the one that tried to convince Hope that her sister was in good hands, even in marrying the great Oneco. She was even the one who lost her arm in the attempt of saving Everell, which we then see that both women have fallen in love with him and Magawisca loves Everell, she lets her love for him go.


2 thoughts on “Catharine Sedgwick, You should have named your book “Magawisca”

  1. Great job on the title and tags! When I google “Hope Leslie should have been titled Magawisca,” your blog post is the first result that comes up! Now readers of Hope Leslie who have the same thought and search the engines for like-minds will definitely come across your blog post! That’s pretty exciting. And your argument in concise, clear, and easy to read. The only thing is I couldn’t find any hyperlinks– I wanted to click on Porter’s article and also find out more about the photo you added from Pinterest– it looks like a beautiful work of art that I’d like to learn more about.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I think it’s really cool that you searched for “Hope Leslie should have been titled Magawisca”, and that my blog post was the first to come up. I really enjoy sharing my perspectives with others. I also really appreciate the feedback for my blog post. Thank you for pointing out the missing finishing touches. I was able to add the hyperlink for Kate Porter’s article but sadly I have to address that I could not find the artist to the artwork I found on pinterest. I searched for “Native American Women Art”, and when I saw this particular artwork I knew that I wanted it for my blog post.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s